The dream of the short-term rental (STR) is enticing: higher daily rates, total control over your property, and no long-term tenants to worry about.
But there is a reason professional property managers exist. Running a successful STR is no longer about just throwing a spare bed on a website; it’s about hospitality, logistics, and reputation management. One bad review can tank your booking rate for months, and one overlooked detail can turn a profitable weekend into a maintenance nightmare.
If you’re moving into the STR market, or your current listing isn’t performing, check if you’re making these five common mistakes.
1. The “Standard Cleaning” Trap
In a long-term rental, “clean” is a baseline. In a short-term rental, “clean” must be surgical. Guests will check for hair in the shower, dust on the baseboards, and crumbs in the toaster. A single stray hair is often the difference between a 5-star and a 3-star review.
-
The Fix: Don’t just hire a cleaner; hire an STR Specialist. Use a detailed turnover checklist that includes “high-touch” items like remotes, light switches, and inside the microwave.
2. Underestimating the “Communication Load”
Unlike long-term tenants who might contact you once a month, STR guests expect instant gratification. “How do I work the TV?” “Where is the extra toilet paper?” “Can we check in 2 hours early?” If you aren’t responding within minutes, you’re losing points.
-
The Fix: Use automated messaging templates for the “Big Three”: The booking confirmation, the check-in instructions (sent 24 hours prior), and the “How is everything?” check-in (sent the morning after arrival).
3. Ignoring the “Boring” Rules (Local Laws)
The biggest mistake you can make is assuming your HOA or city council allows short-term rentals. Many owners have invested thousands in furniture only to be hit with a “Cease and Desist” order and a heavy fine three weeks later.
-
The Fix: Verify your zoning laws and HOA bylaws before you list. Get your short-term rental permit (if required) and ensure you are paying the appropriate occupancy taxes.
4. Setting It and Forgetting It (Pricing)
The market rate for your property on a Tuesday in November is not the same as a Saturday in July. Many owners leave thousands of dollars on the table by setting one “flat rate” for the entire year.
-
The Fix: Use dynamic pricing tools. These tools automatically adjust your rates based on local events, holidays, and competitor occupancy. It ensures you’re never the cheapest (losing money) or the most expensive (losing bookings) in your area.
5. DIY Photography
We live in a “scroll-first” economy. If your main photo is a dark, blurry shot taken on an old smartphone, guests will keep scrolling. You are selling a dream, and that dream starts with lighting and composition.
-
The Fix: Hire a professional real estate photographer. For roughly $150–$300, you will get photos that make your space look larger, brighter, and more professional. This investment usually pays for itself within the first two bookings.
The Bottom Line
Short-term rentals can be a goldmine, but they require a level of operational excellence that most busy property owners simply don’t have the time for. Success in this industry isn’t about being a landlord; it’s about being a super-host.
Feeling overwhelmed by guest messages and turnover schedules? We can manage your listing calendar, handle guest inquiries 24/7, and coordinate with your cleaning crews to ensure every guest gets a 5-star experience without you ever having to lift a finger.
